Hazel McHaffie

Abortion, abduction and Adam Creed

Two young pregnant women go missing. Transpires they’ve been forcibly abducted.
A newborn baby is found dumped in a car park.
A Pro-life organisation is in the spotlight, claiming responsibility for preventing the women terminating their pregnancies
The father of the abandoned baby absconds.

Investigations reveal the first young woman has been held in an underground rat-infested tunnel for a chunk of her pregnancy, fed junk food, forced to defecate where she lay on the filthy ground.
When she’s discovered by an historian investigating the underground labyrinth, she’s barely alive and covered in blood. She dies soon afterwards.

A Bill related to the age of viability for abortion is coming before Parliament.
The Home Secretary, who’s pregnant herself, is threatened.
More babies fall out of the system.

As you might surmise from all this, Detective Inspector Will Wagstaffe aka Staffe faces a fearsomely complex web of deceit involving people across the spectrum of humanity and social status.

All sounds like my kind of material, huh? But  …
Pain of Death – one of a series by Adam Creed – is so complicated that I got lost in the morass of detail and, even making notes to signpost developments, I struggled to follow the strands of each part of the plot. An Independent reviewer wrote: Creed has the smarts to make a mark in an overcrowded field. Hmm, maybe just a tad too smart for the likes of me then. Not my best holiday buy! Sorry.

, , , ,

Comments

A Darker Domain

When I picked up A Darker Domain from a National Trust bookshelf, it was really because I hadn’t read anything by Val McDermid for ages. And because, in this one, she returns to her own roots in Fife, not far from where I Iive.

I knew from the blurb on the back cover that the story line included a kidnap over 20 years ago where one of the hostages ended up dead and her baby son missing. During that same year a pit worker vanished without trace during the miners’ strike of 1984. Cold-case expert DI Karen Pirie is charged with following new leads in both cases.

What I didn’t know was that at the centre is a mother’s desperate search for a relative who might be a bone marrow donor for her little boy, Luke, who has Fanconi’s Anaemia. Yep; shades of ethical dilemmas relating to fertility treatment lying in there somewhere! Time is running out for Luke and no suitable unrelated donor has been found, so mum, Misha, turns to the family. Her father, (Luke’s grandfather) Mike Prentice, is the miner who disappeared and she has not seen him since. Times were desperately difficult back then with no money coming in, and it was assumed he’d gone to Nottingham with a small group of other miners (scabs) to seek paid work down the mines there. Such betrayal brings disgrace on the whole family and neither his wife, Jenny, nor Misha, have made any effort to contact him … until now; now, when he might just be a suitable donor for his grandson. Luke’s plight overrules all other scruples.

The plot thickens when both DI Pirie and a courageous and independent investigative journalist uncover treachery beyond anything expected, the body count rises, and links between the two cases tighten. And Val McDermid is not afraid of gory endings!

Knowing that the author herself grew up in a mining village in Fife, and spent 16 years as a journalist, I could really appreciate the authenticity behind her accounts of both place and profession. She’s always an accomplished and compelling writer; this one had that extra touch for me because of her insider awareness. And in the end the bone marrow donor angle was very peripheral, but I wasn’t disappointed.

 

, , , , , , , ,

Comments

Crime meets religion and ethics

Wow! It’s a blockbuster of a novel at 571 pages, but it surely grips the attention from beginning to end. The book?  Detective, by Arthur Hailey.

The principal character, Detective Sergeant Malcolm Ainslie, is clever, discreet, calm, instinctive, a creative thinker who sees through veneers and hypocrisy, but is well able to keep his own counsel. He’s also most unusual for a policeman – on two counts. One, he’s educated to PhD level; and two, he was formerly a Catholic priest. And there’s no doubt his priesthood and erudition contribute to his being an exceptional sleuth, widely admired and respected.

Over time he’s lost his personal faith, but he has retained much theological and Biblical knowledge, and clung to his strong ethical principles. Indeed, his scruples make for difficulties when he encounters colleagues prepared to bend the rules or take shortcuts or turn a blind eye to crime.

As a priest he’d believed human life was sacrosanct, given by God; now he believes the judicial taking of life morally demeans both those who administer the penalty and the public in whose name executions take place. Furthermore such death is, in a way, a merciful release; in his view a lifetime of imprisonment without parole constitutes a greater punishment.

However, he lives and works in Florida, aka the Sunshine State, which still has the death penalty. Occasionally he’s required to attend such as execution (using the electric chair), and it troubles him deeply. He’s also very conscious that he has personally been instrumental in getting convictions that lead to the death penalty. The author brilliantly captures the horror of watching a terrified fellow human die with thousands of volts of electricity shot through his body.

When a prisoner on Death Row in the last hours of his life pleads for Detective Ainslie to hear his confession, Ainslie has no choice but to revise his holiday plans and drive hundreds of miles to the prison. He was the lead detective in bringing Elroy Doil to justice for a series of truly gruesome murders; no one else will do. And the execution cannot be delayed.

As Ainslie races across country, we’re given the backstory to the murders. Rich elderly couples bound and gagged, butchered in front of each other, and left with rock music playing loudly and certain weird objects left beside them. Doil confesses to killing 14 people but insists he was not instrumental in the high profile slaughter of the City Commissioner and his wife, even though the scene of the crime bore some of the same hallmarks. And Ainslie believes him; he too had his suspicions, and his knowledge of the Book of Revelation contributed to that intuition. The confession minutes before death triggers a forensic re-examination of the Commissioner’s death and presents the whole Police Department with a truly terrible scenario.

The scrupulous attention to detail, the meticulous recording of dates and names, the clever backstory of each character, all mark this novel out as outstanding. The main character might be exceptionally clever, but the author who created him seems to bear many of the same characteristics!

 

, , , , , , , , , , ,

Comments

Books, books and more books!

I’ve just been on a trip from Scotland to Somerset and back, visiting people and places, and I’ve been struck by the sheer number and size of the secondhand book shops and shelves popping up in places like stately homes, National Trust properties, restaurants, and the efforts made to create attractive inviting nooks to sit and enjoy the pleasures of reading. Brings joy to the heart of a writer!! I could easily have filled the boot of the car if I hadn’t restrained myself, and remembered my own already-groaning bookshelves, but as it was I limited purchases to a mere ten:

This week I thought I’d just share some of the imaginative ideas volunteers who clearly love books have given us. So I invite you to sit back and simply savour them.

, , ,

Comments

Peter May – author extraordinaire

On Friday, bestselling Scottish author Peter May died suddenly at his home in the South of France, aged just 74. He’d already decided to retire after writing his last novel: Island of the Dead, due to be published early next year, after which he’d planned a farewell tour promoting it.

Strange that I should have been thinking of him so much during the past week, but so it was. The reason? I’d been travelling through the country as far down as Somerset visiting National Trust properties and their secondhand bookshops. And amongst the collection of books I purchased were no less than three by this well-loved crime writer.

I shall now savour each one with a greater sense of respect and gratitude. His was indeed a prodigious talent.

On my own bookshelves I already have nine of his works. And given the huge number of followers he attracted – over 15 million books sold – his memory will live on far and wide.

Thank you, Peter … if I May!!

, , , , ,

Comments

“No One Can Hurt Him Anymore” …

“No One Can Hurt Him Anymore” …
because he’s dead.
At the tender age of 10.
At the hands of someone who should have cared for him.
Under the eyes of officials and authorities charged with protecting him.
In spite of innumerable warnings and reports of cruelty, and clear evidence of abuse.

His name was Andrew J Schwarz aka A.J. He lived in Florida from April 1983 to May 1993.

This was a lad let down on all sides. His short life was one filled with harsh treatment, rejection, degradation, deprivation, at the hands of both his birth mother, Ilene, (and her paramours), and his stepmother, Jessica.
His whole life was a living hell.

A.J.’s story makes harrowing reading and generates a powerful feeling of bewilderment and incomprehension that so many red flags could be ignored or buried. And it’s right that those failures should be exposed in this full account of his life and death. But it’s a hauntingly difficult tale to stay with, especially during the trial where witnesses for the defence blatantly lie, and where protection officials demonstrate horrifying negligence and incompetence. No wonder grown men, professionals with yards of experience, wept. And no wonder the chief prosecutor, Scott Cupp, who co-wrote the book with author Carol J Rothgeb, said Jessica Schwarz was the personification of evil.

Killing Me GentlyI added this book to my reading list when I was researching parents who deliberately harm their children for my own creative writing pre-pandemic (Killing Me Gently), but have only just ordered a copy and read it. No one would have believed me if I had told this tale.

And indeed publishers  were reluctant to take on “No One Can Hurt Him Anymore”. Child abuse – especially on this scale –
is just too painful a subject. Yes, it is. It’s the kind of pain that creeps into your dreams. It’s the kind of pain that makes you weak.

A.J.’s story illustrates the danger of putting undue emphasis on blood/family relationship and the rights of parents/families. Cupp pleads eloquently for more emphasis on the best interests of the child. His hope in writing this book is that A.J.’s tragic and senseless death will help to renew the debate on how to manage cases of child abuse. And in drawing attention to it here I both echo that hope and cry out for some glimmer of justice for that vulnerable little soul.

, , , , , ,

Comments

Terminally Ill Adults Bill

I know … I know … we’ve been here so many times, haven’t we?! Big sigh. But I have to stay fair- and open-minded on the subject.

I confess, every time the topic of Assisted Dying comes under widespread scrutiny my mind and my heart are torn yet again. Because I can appreciate the sense and sincerity and wisdom offered from both sides.

So, on Friday I listened carefully to yet another debate in parliament on the subject. The courage and compelling emotional truth from those with first-hand experience of living with terminal illness; the pain of those who’ve watched loved ones die in harrowing circumstances; the eloquence of doctors coping with the lived reality for their patients; the fear of and for disabled people and the vulnerable; the frustration of those who’ve worked tirelessly to bring the bill to the lawmakers … it was all there on view. Moving and compelling. At times, though, when seats rapidly emptied, or colleagues interrupted or chatted together during speeches, or fidgeted with their mobile phones, I got a sense of a little less respect and empathy and solemnity than last time – perhaps it was a matter of time/patience/deja-vu? – but nonetheless the critical issues were certainly covered by the exchanges.

And then came the all-important vote.
Defeat.
By 16 votes.
And this time the House of Lords can’t be blamed; the elected members in the Commons did this all on their own.

Another bill will surely be introduced at some point in the future, but that’s it for now.

However, what I personally take away from this latest stage is gratitude that so much emphasis was placed on the need for better palliative care. I know of a number of patients/friends who were given exemplary end-of-life care, but I also know only too well it’s a post-code lottery. Whilst there are many pros and cons attached to the question of assisted death, there are no contraindications for the matter of medical and social support at the end of life: every single person deserves the best. There can be no second chance.

And NHS Specialist in Palliative Medicine, author and campaigner, Dr Rachel Clarke, (one of my heroes) summed it up perfectly in her eloquent open letter to the Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, the day after the vote. The issue that united everyone she said was ‘the appalling underfunding of palliative and social care which inflicts so much avoidable suffering on people with terminal illnesses‘. She called it ‘a national disgrace’ that only 25-33% of hospice care is government funded. She told him that if he saw what she sees he would recoil: ‘Do you know that I sometimes have to have end-of-life conversations with patients who are dying on trolleys in hospital corridors – because there is nowhere else to put them?‘ And given that the Burnham family have been bereaved this very week, I suspect this would have even greater impact.

Dr Clarke appealed to him, begged him indeed, ‘as a decent man‘, to put an end to this intolerable situation, to make dying people a government priority … ‘You are the Prime Minister’ … ‘this is something you have the power to change’.

If the heat and passion and persistence fuelling this ongoing debate does nothing more, I for one hope it leads to this improvement at least. And swiftly.

 

 

 

ٍ

, , , , , ,

Comments

Physician-assisted suicide or mercy killing – a medical thriller

Mercy by Michael and Daniel Parker (a father and son duo) begins with a quote from the Dalai Lama:
Love and compassion are necessities, not luxuries. Without them humanity cannot survive;
and ends with
Compassion is what binds us. It’s what makes living worthwhile.
A neat bookending of the substance of this novel which centres on the controversy around mercy killing. Yep, I’m back in my familiar milieu. And given that the topic comes before the UK Parliament again tomorrow, it’s topical.

The narrative opens with a chapter recounting the deliberate killing of a patient in end-stage cardiac failure – told from his perspective. But something’s decidedly wrong here. It’s certainly not a mutually agreed procedure. We feel the patient’s terror, and are hooked in immediately. And then there’s the person administering the lethal medication: coldly dispassionate not gently reassuring. We’re alert to trouble from the outset.

By contrast, the main protagonist in this story is emergency room intensivist, Dr Julie Devereux, a passionate but compassionate advocate for death with dignity. Her ambition is to take officialdom and government out of the equation and let the patient with his/her doctor decide together what’s best for them, always staying within the law.

Then one day the patient is her fiancé Sam, hideously injured in a three-vehicle collision which she personally witnessed as he was driving his motorcycle ahead of her on a fast road. Along with multiple fractures and serious open wounds, Sam has suffered a crush injury to his fourth cervical vertebra – he faces the rest of his life as a permanent quadriplegic with a tracheotomy, requiring a raft of medication to keep his body functioning.

When he emerges from oblivion and is able to comprehend the desperate situation, Sam begs Julie to help him die.
‘I can’t live like this … You’ve fought for death with dignity for years, now fight for me.’

She’s appalled by the idea when it applies to the man she loves, but he throws her own words back at her:
‘The best care should be made available to every patient, but a patient deserves the right to hasten death to avoid inhumane suffering or escape from a life turned unbearable.’

Now, on the other side of the situation herself, Julie does an about-turn, arguing passionately against all the speeches she’s made, all the papers she’s written, all the arguments she’s employed for mercy killing – for continuing life.

But then something inexplicable happens. Sam suddenly collapses and dies. Julie is acutely aware that something isn’t right. He might have wanted fiercely to die, but he was incapable of doing anything himself to induce death. She didn’t help him, so … what happened? Was this a medical anomaly or did someone do something to cause his death?  She starts asking questions, challenging results, and piecing together a bewildering picture. Because the autopsy results indicate a very rare stress phenomenon: takotsubo cardiomyopathy, an instant reaction to an extreme stressful stimulus resulting in an abnormal surge of adrenaline, constricting the coronary arteries, and diminishing blood flow. It seems Sam was literally scared to death.

Julie begins to investigate. She unearths other similar deaths, and gradually a picture emerges of skull-duggery beyond belief. Her search takes her to interview a convicted murderer in prison, to talk to ardent campaigners for life, and experts in many branches of medicine and science. The common link between all the unexpected deaths initially seems to be this enlargement of part of the heart: takotsubo cardiomyopathy … or is it? Why did all these people develop hives just before death? Could it be an acute allergic response? If so to what? And who is behind it?
Administrators desperate to stop the rapid drain of money from the hospital?
Doctors with reputations to maintain?
Parents wanting to avenge their dead children?
Aggrieved staff looking for revenge for dismissal?
Someone with their own personal agenda?
Who?

Still more patients die. When their lab results come back they make no sense; no, more than that, they’re downright sinister. Allergic cardiac events, tics, massive overdoses …?? And a common feature seems to be that all the victims are very ill, severely incapacitated, or at the end of their lives – some even asking to die. It looks on the surface like a macabre version of mercy killing.

It’s now no longer a case of finding out who or what killed Sam; it’s a race to stop more people dying.

But what Julie doesn’t know is that with every piece of the jigsaw she discovers, she’s putting herself in greater danger. Her every word, every movement, is being monitored by a paid assassin who’s simply biding his time. One by one her supporters are picked off. And her own previous high profile in relation to assisted dying becomes a weapon in the hands of her adversaries. She herself becomes a prime suspect.

We’re kept in suspense until the very end, and I for one did not suspect the person who actually killed Sam, though I was suspicious of some of the administrators charged with balancing the books. A thriller in the best sense, and one in my own field of interest! Wahey!!

[NB. Meticulous research went into this story but just for the record, it’s not sparrows but starlings that form murmurations! (pp222-3) But in a work of this calibre it’s actually quite comforting to note a tiny human chink in the overall brilliance!]

, , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Comments

Jubilate

…challenges accepted notions of sickness and health, duty and sacrifice, the nature of miracles and the workings of grace

…convincingly, and imaginatively, interrogated faith, belief and the gritty struggle to live with grace

…combines a moving story of love against the odds with a moral debate on the nature of faith… a highly readable novel, full of humour and warmth… a novelist with the courage to tackle groundbreaking subjects

…the ethics of choice, and how we care for one another, are made to matter

… exposing the frailty in us all

Yeah, that sounds like my kind of reading! The book is Jubilate by Michael Arditti. And the reviews are glowing.

At the heart of the novel is a touching love story. Gillian is a dutiful Catholic wife approaching middle age. She accompanies her brain-damaged and errant husband, Richard, on a pilgrimage to Lourdes where she falls in love with Vincent, a lapsed Catholic and now agnostic investigative journalist and documentary film-maker bent on exploring, perhaps even exploding, the myths around miracle cures in the shrine’s 150th anniversary year.

The narrative spans just 5 days.The voices of Vincent and Gillian alternate with five chapters from each perspective – hers backwards from Friday to Monday; his forwards Monday to Friday.

Gillian joins the Jubilate, an independent pilgrimage of about two hundred people, on the recommendation of her mother-in-law who’s constantly hoping for a miracle cure for her son. Vincent is filming the events, wanting to shed light on their activities and motivation and experiences. Both are deeply vulnerable with great sadnesses and frustrations in their lives. Their mutual attraction is instant and powerful, their fundamental differences challenging and provocative. Can mutual respect count for more than agreement?

But alongside their immediate personal emotions, both are grappling with deep existential questions:
How can God – if he exists – allow random illnesses, especially in innocent children?
This amazing world – created or the product of chance?
Was the world created simply to reflect the Creator’s glory and give endless praise?
Does an awesome God really care about the small sins of insignificant people – like their adultery?
Does God punish people in ways that fit the crime/sin?
What makes us human? When does life cease to have meaning?
Where does duty end and sacrifice begin?
How do you decide between God’s intervention and coincidence?

Arditti makes no attempt to answer all their questions, but he does capture the atmosphere of an iconic place that encourages contemplation, and allows for miracles other than medical healing.

 

, , , , , , , , ,

Comments

Deeper darker psychological thrills!

Ever since I started to study psychological thriller writing, I’ve continued to seize opportunities to examine how the masters of the genre do it. Recently I’ve mentioned a couple of JP Delaney‘s novels on this blog, but in Believe Me he takes things one step further.

‘… a pitch-perfect psychological thriller’, Lee Child reckons! (Wouldn’t we all love to gain that particular accolade?)

Claire Wright is a 25 year old British actor, who since the age of eleven has been pretending to be someone other than an orphan girl who’s been in and out of foster homes, desperate to love and be loved. Her scholarship with the Actors Studio at Pace University in New York covers some of her tuition fees but not her living costs and here she is in one of the most expensive cities in the world.  Her visa allows her to work as long as it’s not on the university campus, but she has no green card. So she takes a job working for a firm of divorce lawyers, posing as an easy pick-up in hotel bars in order to entrap errant husbands. She’s not proud of the work she does – breaking up families – but she is proud of how well she does it. She’s a consummate actor.

But then one of the men she’s supposed to expose as a cheat, Patrick Fogler, becomes chief suspect in a murder investigation. His wife is found brutally murdered in her hotel room soon after Claire meets her. He’s also known to have been in the vicinity of several other unsolved killings. What’s more, he’s an academic with a penchant for the macabre works of Charles Baudelaire, and many of the murders bear distinct overtones of the fate of women in his poetry. But there’s nothing definitive to provide concrete evidence of Fogler’s guilt.

Then Claire is offered an attractive deal by the police: take on a terrifying role as someone Patrick would be attracted to, in return for a green card … if she survives!! She agrees and it becomes an all-consuming role requiring her to completely submit to the part of the character she’s supposed to be. She attends some of Fogler’s lectures in order to start up a conversation and intrigue him, and they begin a tense relationship, both suspicious of the other, but becoming increasingly in thrall to each other. The whole enterprise takes her into dangerous and mind-bending places: into police custody, into prison and a psychiatric facility; deeper and deeper into the psyche and heart of Patrick, and the reader can’t be sure anything is as it appears.

It’s a tense and constantly spinning tale with so many twists and turns that I gave up trying to decide who was guilty, who was sane, who was real, who was play-acting, and just allowed the narrative to unspool. Because, convoluted and confusing and unreliable it may be, unsavoury and unsettling too, but it’s certainly cleverly constructed. I was intrigued to discover this is its second iteration, the first having flopped early on in Delaney’s career. This time round he’s definitely crackled it!

One particularly neat and unusual ploy adopted by the author is to record some scenes as scripts for a play, with instructions for the actors, and lines of dialogue, as if Claire as actress is picturing them in her head. It fits perfectly with the theme of the novel and the part acting plays in the whole story.

Oh, and the short chapters – 106 of them in less than 400 pages – do help those pages to keep turning.

, , , , ,

Comments

Previous Posts

Die Bedeutung des kreativen Schreibens in der modernen Literatur The Power of Storytelling The Art of Storytelling and the Rising Popularity of Games Like Aviator